Lighthouse Hotel - Key West Historic Inns

Recent Reviews: 177

• User:278charlenem

  Trip type: Family

  Lighthouse was perfect

  31 Mar 2026

  I brought my big dog with me and this place was perfect for both of us. Dog friendly, parking easy, room was nice and best of all Jefferson made me and my family drinks while we caught op on our trip. Bonus, the pool was a bonus because it was warm. General Manager, General Manager at Lighthouse Hotel - Key West Historic Inns, responded to this review Dear Charlene,Thank you for your review. It's an honor knowing we succeeded in providing you and your canine companion with such an incredible visit! We'll share your compliments with Jefferson regarding his skillful bartending, and we hope you come back soon to Lighthouse Hotel.

  Read more

• User:Mary B

  Trip type: Couples

  Lovely, Secluded Haven in the Middle of the Action

  31 Mar 2026

  Beautiful property with an historic and welcoming vibe. Very friendly, accommodating staff. Lemmi and Eddie did all they could to make our stay great!Lovely decks, porches, and niches all around with plenty of green, shade, and seating. Nice, heated pool. Self service coffee, tea, and fruit available all day in the poolside breakfast area/bar.Little three inch rise /step just outside our upper floor "skinny" room, needs a yellow stripe all the way across it, as it is so easy to miss, especially stepping down, and most especially at night. My husband and I missed it repeatedly, which I am sure is not unusual for guests, who are naturally looking to the lighthouse or pool view as they step out of their rooms, and not to the floor / deck. We did not fall, but to do so would be easy. General Manager, General Manager at Lighthouse Hotel - Key West Historic Inns, responded to this review Dear Mary,It was a pleasure having you stay with us at Lighthouse Hotel. We’re delighted to hear that your visit felt both relaxing and memorable, and that our welcoming atmosphere and inviting outdoor spaces made your time with us so enjoyable. It also means a lot to know that Lemmi and Eddie left such a positive impression with their warm service. Also, we appreciate you bringing your concern to our attention. The issue you’ve described will be carefully reviewed by our leadership team. Thank you for your thoughtful feedback, and we hope to welcome you back for another wonderful stay.

  Read more

• User:279kathaleenh

  Trip type: Couples

  A lovely inn and a fantastic bartender!

  26 Mar 2026

  We thoroughly enjoy our time at the hotel. Quiet and convenient to the amenities we enjoy—good food and the Hemingway House and the Green Parrot for music. The pool atmosphere promotes conversation with other guests, and Isabel’s served up nice drinks and a delicious continental breakfast. Particularly enjoyable was our hours spent just chatting with Jefferson Alejandror, the bartender, on our last day. He made sure that we had water for hike back to the ferry, and he asked good questions. He knows how to talk to others in a mature and engaging way. He will far! We really enjoyed our conversation with him!

  Read more

• User:rebecca h

  Trip type: Family

  Perfect place to hook up with family 😉

  25 Mar 2026

  Was wonderful, I came down to meet family from Cudjoe Key, would stay with you guys again.

• User:JoAnn M

  Trip type: Family

  A wonderful-place to stay, pool & surroundings are the Key West experience. Directly across from the Hemingway mansion.

  25 Mar 2026

  we had the best time at the lighthouse Hotel. Great accommodations and location. The staff were so helpful and welcoming. Treated us like the. The bartenders Alejandro and Jefferson were A+ plus plus. There is a bar that opens at eight in the morning until 6 PM at night with delicious cocktails available. Continental breakfast is out of this world with fresh fruit, meat, lox and bagels. And all that you would need. so many more staff that we do not recall their names, but they were a plus. Gave us great travel information, directions to locations & recommendations. Our stay in Key West was far above in any other we have had. We will definitely be coming back.

  Read more