Molly Pitcher Inn Red Bank

Recent Reviews: 676

• User:Passport742262

  Trip type: Couples

  Relaxing day at the pool

  31 Aug 2026

  Lovely day and service was great Kelsey Hanlon, Guest Services / Front Office at Molly Pitcher Inn, responded to this review Thank you for the wonderful feedback! We’re so glad you had an awesome pool day and enjoyed the friendly, attentive service from our poolside team. We hope to welcome you back to the Molly Pitcher Inn again soon!

• User:Passport47728

  Trip type:

  Wedding!

  11 Aug 2026

  We had my daughter's wedding at The Molly and I can't recommend it highly enough! Our guests were blown away by the quality of the food and the service. Over half of our guests came from out of town and loved their stay. Special thanks to Lauren, Christian and Anne! Kelsey Hanlon, Guest Services / Front Office at Molly Pitcher Inn, responded to this review Thank you so much for your wonderful review! We’re truly honored that you chose the Molly Pitcher Inn for such a special celebration. It means so much to hear that you, your daughter, and your guests had such a memorable experience and that the food and service exceeded your expectations.We’ll be sure to share your kind words with Lauren, Christian, and Anne. Congratulations to your daughter and her new spouse, and thank you for allowing us to be part of such a beautiful occasion!

  Read more

• User:Timi-Jean B

  Trip type:

  Lovely hotel for event

  28 Jul 2026

  Attended an event and stayed at Molly Pitcher's. The room was small however everyone was so professional and helpful that the size of the room was a minor issue. The bar staff was efficient. It was nice to have coffee and pastry in the morning. Parking was ample despite it being a very busy weekend. The pool was nice to lounge around. We were definitely pleased with our stay. Kelsey Hanlon, Guest Services / Front Office at Molly Pitcher Inn, responded to this review Thank you for the perfect rating and for sharing such a thoughtful review. We’re delighted to hear that you enjoyed your stay with us while attending your event.We’re pleased that our team’s professionalism and helpful service stood out, and that you enjoyed the bar, complimentary morning coffee and pastries, convenient parking, and relaxing pool area. We also appreciate your understanding regarding the room size, as our historic property offers rooms with unique layouts and character.Thank you again for your kind words. We’re so glad you had a wonderful experience and hope to welcome you back to the Molly Pitcher Inn again soon.

  Read more

• User:Nancy C

  Trip type: Couples

  Honesty and Efficiency at The Molly Picher Inn

  19 Jul 2026

  While staying at the Molly Pitcher Inn, I dropped the paper coaster holding six pieces of my jewelry. I could find five of the pieces. The sixth piece, my mother’s wedding band could not be found. After hours of searching with the housekeeping staff to no avail, the front desk took my contact information and said if it was found they would get in touch with me.Almost a month to the day later, I received an email from the housekeeping director that my ring was found.The honesty of the housekeeper who found it and the efficiency of the front desk staff member that kept my contact information cannot be praised enough. I thank them wholeheartedly for what they did. Them and Saint Anthony! Kelsey Hanlon, Guest Services / Front Office at Molly Pitcher Inn, responded to this review Thank you for the perfect rating and for sharing such a meaningful story. We are truly grateful for your kind words and are so happy that your mother’s wedding band was found and returned to you.We are especially proud of our housekeeping and front desk teams for their honesty, care, and follow-through. Moments like this reflect the integrity and dedication our team brings to their work every day, and we will be sure to share your heartfelt recognition with them.Thank you again for taking the time to share your experience and for recognizing our team. We’re honored to have been part of reuniting you with such a sentimental piece, and we hope to welcome you back to the Molly Pitcher Inn again soon.

  Read more

• User:amshafer121

  Trip type: Couples

  The Pitcher has Pizazz

  11 Jul 2026

  Stayed overnight and the Pitcher was a lovely old hotel. If you appreciate antique crystal door knobs on the closets -and an actual spacious closet- then this place is for you. The bathroom was very clean and small- as you’d expect from the 19th century. Similarly, the shower water pressure left something to be desired- like, pressure. The mattresses were very comfy and the bed linens of excellent quality. Each bed had 6 standard pillows- all of premium loft- no horsehair suspected in any of the bedding. We would stay here again in a second. If Molly were alive today, they’d have much to brag about. Kelsey Hanlon, Guest Services / Front Office at Molly Pitcher Inn, responded to this review Thank you for the perfect rating and for such a wonderfully entertaining review! We’re delighted that you appreciated the historic character and unique details of the Molly Pitcher Inn, right down to the antique crystal door knobs and spacious closets.We’re especially glad you enjoyed the comfortable mattresses, quality linens, and exceptionally clean room. We appreciate your comments regarding the shower pressure as well, and we’ll be sure to share that feedback with our team.Your closing sentiment gave us a smile. We’re honored that you would stay with us again “in a second,” and we hope to welcome you back for another stay with plenty of Pizazz!

  Read more