The Tillary Hotel



6+ photos
This hotel is located in the heart of New York City.

85 Flatbush Ave Extension
Check-in from 3:00 PM · Check-out by 11:00 AM

85 Flatbush Ave Extension
Check-in from 3:00 PM · Check-out by 11:00 AM
Average
178 reviewsUser: jdkw1720cc
Trip type: Family
Second Floor Bar Waste of Time
Second floor bar is a joke. Went in to order drinks & got told they only had a couple drinks on their menu. Asked if they could make Tito’s & tonics with limes. Was told no limes owner doesn’t care… wow shows poor culture & most of all customer service General Manager, General Manager at The Tillary Hotel, responded to this review Thank you for sharing your feedback with us. We're… Second floor bar is a joke. Went in to order drinks & got told they only had a couple drinks on their menu. Asked if they could make Tito’s & tonics with limes. Was told no limes owner doesn’t care… wow shows poor culture & most of all customer ser…
User: Rich H
Trip type: Couples
Horrendous and not honourable
????? Security failure ruined our stay — refund still not honouredWe stayed at The Tillary Hotel from 9th–11th July 2026. During our first night, hotel staff issued a key card for our room to another guest, who let themselves into our room at 2:42am. We were badly shaken and didn't sleep for the rest of the night.A duty manager we spoke with — a genuinely pleasant woman, though we didn't catch her… ????? Security failure ruined our stay — refund still not honouredWe stayed at The Tillary Hotel from 9th–11th July 2026. During our first night, hotel staff issued a key card for our room to another guest, who let themselves into our room at 2:42am. We were b…
User: Suzanne R
Trip type: Family
By far the worst hotel I have ever stayed in.
User: Mark L
Trip type: Family
A Shocking Lack of Compassion and Basic Human Decency — Stay Away
User: alvaroz289
Trip type: Business
Nightmare!!!! No guarantees! Customer service never refunded!
Worst hotel in Brooklyn! My room was dirty, the toilet bowl was broken, the coffee machine didn't work. They are completely understaffed and the help desk lady was not trained to do her job! The maintenance guy just dropped the new coffee machine blocking the entrance... and the WORST THING: I stayed only one night and agreed the refund of the next nights... But the refund never happened, the mana… Worst hotel in Brooklyn! My room was dirty, the toilet bowl was broken, the coffee machine didn't work. They are completely understaffed and the help desk lady was not trained to do her job! The maintenance guy just dropped the new coffee machine blocking the…
Weekly in your inbox — handpicked package deals and price drops before they sell out.
Our Privacy Policy